A Session on Neshannock Creek
3/26/26
After picking up my new Scott 8’ 6” 4 weight Session, from the Neshannock Creek Fly Shop, I was anxious to try it out on the Neshannock Creek. After false casting it, on the lawn out front, I placed the rod in the rod rack outside the shop and drove up to the big parking area to get my gear on. A friend of mine followed me and we got dressed for a trout session on the creek.
The water was in great condition. Not crystal clear but just enough color for fish finding offerings. It was already in the upper 50° range with a slight breeze. The sun wasn’t up above the far tree line yet which shaded the creek water. I attached a Woolly Bugger to the tippet and stepped into the water upstream from the shop. I was expecting to feel a rush of cold water around my hip waders but now, thinking about it, I was either anxious to start fishing the new rod or the water just wasn’t that cold to notice.
The rod itself felt light in hand. I bought the rod, being it was considered a fast action with a soft tip. When I cast it, it came natural to me. The soft tip they mentioned was pretty close to my Winston Boron rod with the Winston feel. The rod wasn’t as forgiving and therefore roll casting was more improved compared to the Winston which wasn’t worth 2 cents when trying to roll cast a weighted streamer within a short distance. Don’t get me wrong, my 6 weight Winston overhand casts foam poppers and weighted Buggers with ease out quite a distance but trying to roll cast weighted offerings up close wasn’t meant for this rod. The Scott rod on the other hand roll casts fine with the weight forward floating line and a weighted bugger attached.
Overhand casting the weighted bugger mid-creek to far side was easy and not much finesse needed. After about 10 minutes or so, without only one bump and no hook up, I knotted on one of my Triple Threat streamers. The rod pitched the unweighted, cone head Triple Threat with ease. My third cast was nearer to the far bank and I let it swing freely down creek. I felt a grab just before the line straightened and reared back the rod for the hook set. The floating line came off the water as the line tightened and my first trout, with the new rod, was tugging fiercely against the oncoming current. I could feel the upper section of the rod flexing as I brought the tugging trout to the net. “No problem here,” I thought. I took out my camera for a picture of my first trout on the new Scott rod.
Small stoneflies started to hatch and skirt across the water. I knotted on a dry stonefly I tie and casted out trying to get a hook up but the trout weren’t interested. Most of the rises were very sporadic and most looked like they were taking emergers and not sipping the surface. Without a dry strike I tried nymph fishing without any hits. Back to streamer fishing I worked my way down creek. Down creek I caught one more trout on a Woolly Bugger but I still had dry fly fishing on my mind. There were a couple of risers down creek, during the stonefly hatch, but not as many as were up creek. Though I tried for the few risers they wouldn’t take either of my dry stoneflies. I hooked the dry to the hook keeper and went back up creek.
By now there were less fishermen, and I waded within distance of most of the fish I saw rising earlier. Every once in a while, a gust of wind would blow up creek. Casting the dry across the wind wasn’t a problem. The fast action rod performed great as I expected it to for this was the reason I bought the faster action rod. I was only able to raise one trout on my dry stonefly but didn’t get him hooked. The trout came up right in front of me within my vision of seeing him rise. Maybe I was so excited I pulled the line and dry off the water before he even got it to his mouth. Whatever the reason, I never felt the slightest pinch upon missing him. It was like knowing full well you can hit a lazy stink bug flying around by swatting at it but not even grazing it with your hand. That trout wasn’t going to be fooled again, nor did I have any other sporadic trout interested.
Sometimes I would see a trout surface for a fly on the water, but I couldn’t see anything else on the water except a stonefly now and then but not as often as earlier. Maybe there was something out there I couldn’t see or the fish were grabbing small emergers? I decided to knot on a #18 BWO. There was one trout that came up pretty regularly out towards the far side of the creek. I started making long casts towards the area and I knew I was getting my dry within his zone. I knew I had to just wait him out and eventually I felt he would come up.
My overhand cast cut through the slight breeze and, with a tight loop, fell upon the water up from the area the trout was rising within. I watched as the BWO CDC wing drift upon the water in the distance. A trout rose quickly and gulped at it. I swung the rod up creek and pulled in line with my left hand. The long length of line sprung from the water and I felt the resistance on the other end. The trout felt like he was pretty furious as he battled against the current and the tight line. He wasn’t too graceful once I netted him and was as if begging to be released. Oh well, he got his picture anyway before I released him.
Now that was pretty cool. Got my first trout on a dry fly for 2026. Now it was time to try and fool another. Within a couple more casts I felt something was wrong with the casting. Bringing in the line and tippet my dry BWO was gone. The end of the 5x tippet was curled. Evidently the knot gave out. Good thing it didn’t give out upon bringing in the trout!
I found another BWO and knotted it on. I caught one more trout that occasionally was rising within a small run made by a boulder just below the surface. He came up as if he was going for an emerger before it took flight. I was ready when he reached the surface and yanked back the rod and line. He was already hooked when his momentum caused his body to break the surface displaying half his body. I noticed right off it was another rainbow trout before he disappeared beneath. We had a good go around before I got him swung around in slower current in the net.
Well, that was 2 on a dry fly! Now to see if I could fool another.
It took some time with many casts trying to get a fish to rise. I was mostly blind casting out there as there weren’t any risers during the time. It was like throwing rocks in a cut down corn field trying to stir a ringneck to flush.
I glanced up creek at another fisherman and by chance a fish rose almost within 20’ of me upstream and away. Now, I miss more trout dry fly fishing up creek from them than fishing across or down creek. I’m not sure why? Well, I wasn’t going to move and disturb the water for a better angle and a downstream cast. With the wind blowing up creek, against my back, I made a sharp high back cast and pointed the rod tip upstream on my forward cast. The wind carried my dry a little further than what I thought of would have liked but it fell upon the surface safely. It looked like it was going to drift into the fishes zone as I brought in line trying to keep it taunt. The trout rose right up creek from me, and I swear it was within 10 feet. There was quite of bit of line slack on the water as I thought my dry was already passed his eyesight. I quickly raised the rod as high as I could and stripped the slack line off the water as quickly as I could. I saw the trout head turn towards me as the hook set. Maybe I pulled a little harder than I needed to, but my knots held as the trout went under and scurried around. I took control after he scurried down creek and was able to scoop him up in the net. The hook was in the roof of his mouth. He settled down enough that I was able to dislodge it, with my hemostats, without any harm. A quick picture and he was on his way safely out of the net.
After that Kevin and I fished for another hour or so. I couldn’t get another strike on either a dry or a streamer. Downstream I saw Kevin bringing in a trout. His rod was well bowed and it looked like he had a good fish on the other end. When I saw him headed to the bank with the trout in the net I figured he had a lunker. I was too far, in the water, up creek from him to try to get to him for a picture. After releasing the trout he looked my way with his hands apart imitating how long the trout was.
When we were ready to go he told me that was the biggest trout he ever caught in the Neshannock Creek. We headed to our vehicles and called it a day.
My new Scott Session rod is an exceptional rod by my terms. It handled well with the wind, casting streamers and dry flies and bringing in frisky trout. It’s definitely a keeper and I know I’ll be using it often.


















