Tionesta
Caddis
4/30/22
After
a morning of turkey hunting I fished an area trout were rising the
day before. The water had come down a bit overnight and was clear as
moonshine. The sun was bright and it got warm in the afternoon while
I was fishing. I expected to see trout rising to the black stoneflies
but didn’t see any rising while I was fishing. I knew the area they
had been rising, so I decided to cast a dry out there and see if I
could make them rise. It took sometime to convince a few but I ended
up making a few rise to my stonefly dry pattern.
About
2:00pm I decided to head back to camp. On the way I stopped and
fished a couple of spots along the Tionesta but quickly left without
a catch. By the time I got to camp, around 4:00pm, I was pretty worn
out and ready to rest. I still had my waders on and my fly rod was
still in the back of the truck. After parking I went down to the
crick just to see if anything was happening. That’s when the fun
started!
Recently
I haven’t been fishing around camp because I wasn’t catching many
trout for the time I spent on the water. They didn’t seem to want
streamers and I only caught a couple on stonefly nymphs. It also gets
fished often by bait fishermen so maybe the trout were just wary of
biting. Anyhow…
Looking
over the water I saw 1 then 2 trout rising across creek. My heart
started to pump a little faster and when they talk about someone
getting a second wind, well those rises just put some excitement in
this tired body.
I
got my fly rod out the back of the truck, put on my vest and grabbed
a few cigars. I wasn’t sure what the trout were rising to but as I
walked upstream along the bank, to get a better angle, I brushed
against a tree branch. In doing so a bunch of small caddis flew from
the branches. They looked to be around a size #18 or even a #20. I
figured they were the little olive body caddis that loiter around
this time of spring. I had a small box of imitations in my vest the
same size. Though I had 5x tippet already knotted on the leader I
figured I’d stay with that set up. If the trout won’t hit then
I’d knot on 6x which I usually do for clear water conditions and
such small dry flies.
As
I waded out I noticed these little caddis fluttering around the
surface like a colony of bees around a flower garden. It was hard to
see any of these tiny caddis on the surface, due to the glare, but
the trout evidently found one now and then. I noticed a flat rock
below the surface about a quarter of the way across the crick. It was
a little deeper getting to it but once on it I was only thigh high
deep. I knotted on one of my #18 olive caddis and pulled line out
through the rod eyes. I had plenty of room for my backcast so my
concentration was on any risers that so happened. It didn’t take
long for a trout to rise to show me where he was at.
The
first rise was upstream to my left a good distance but manageable. I
took out line with each false cast until I figured the distance.
Forward I watched the line tight loop forward and then slap and splash
water when the line hit the surface. This is when I realized that I
was using weight forward line. Compared to doubletaper line the
weight forward makes more of a splash then any double taper line I’ve
used for dry fly fishing. (I would argue this point with anyone.)
In
this respect I have to change my forward casting stroke. Across crick
with the current is no problem but upstream or downstream I’ll use
a different approach. Normally with DT line I’ll back up my forward
cast just before it hits the water so I get small S’ turn slack as
the fly line lays upon the surface. In this way the dry fly will have more time and distance to drift drag free to the feeding trout. Sure I’ll
have to be ready and quicker on the hook set but I’ve been doing
this long enough I know how to control my line. With weight forward
line I have a different approach. Though I’ll still want some slack
for a drag free drift my technique is a little different.
On
my cast forward I want to make sure my fly is extended as far as
possible from my fly line. This isn’t too hard casting forward just
making sure the splash of the fly line isn’t over the trout’s
head. Doing this I want to make sure the dry hits the surface first
before the fly line. To do this I definitely make an overhead cast keeping the rod high on the forward
cast, stopping short of full draw, and then slightly wristing the rod
tip higher. This brings the fly line upward letting the dry hit the
water first. I always figure if a trout is feeding it looks at the
first thing that hits the water and if the fly line causes a
commotion first the trout may never look further at my offering.
It
took a couple of casts but the trout wasn’t interested or wary
cause of my first cast. No problem, there were others to catch. The
other trout I saw rise earlier was downstream and to my right well
within my casting range. Downstream casting is not much of a problem
with weight forward line as long as you get the dry way ahead of the
feeding zone before the fly line hits the water. On my second cast I
was pretty sure it was drifting near the feeding zone. The trout rose
and took it unaware it was attached to tippet, leader, fly line,
reel and me!! I reared back and the line tightened. He scurried about
tugging and jerking the line like trying to bring a rusted bucket
up through a well banging against the side walls. #1 was in the net
safely.
A
trout rose not that far in front of me as I was letting the trout go.
I made a short cast just upstream from his last rise. He took my dry
caddis like a cat lapping up spilled milk. I wristed a hook set and
#2 was in the net.
Every
time I saw a rise I concentrated on the feeding zone and just about
caught every trout that rose. I lost a couple before netting them but
I was just as happy fooling these trout.
I
made a blind cast across and down from where I stood. Most of the
trout was near the far bank where colder water flowed from the run
off from the steep hillside. I watched as my drag free dry continued
with the current toward another trouts feeding zone. Unexpectedly a
trout purposed, at a 90° angle, at my dry that swam out from the far
bank. I had plenty of slack in the line but my instincts took over
and pulling line in with my rod free hand while quickly raising the
rod with my other, made the hook set on time. This trout felt a
little heavier as he fought aggressively to the net.
Without
seeing any more risers within casting distance I waded out towards
the bank and moved upstream for the others I saw rising. The water
was a little shallower upstream so I was able to still get out near
the middle of the crick without getting waist deep. I tried for the
trout that eluded me earlier upstream from where I stood but he was
still being stubborn or still wary of my presence.
I
picked off a couple more trout casting nearer to the far bank with
long casts. After releasing a trout I looked down crick and was going
to attempt to try for the stubborn trout again when I noticed a small
swirl on the surface before my intended target. If I wasn’t looking
that way at the time I would never of known he was there.
Occasionally a riffled swirl would appear on the surface from the
undercurrent deflecting from its course around a larger rock on the
crick bed but still well below the surface thus causing a disturbance
to the surface water. What I saw was definitely a sipping trout rise.
He was trying to be as casually inconspicuous as if he knew I was
here but was hungry enough to take a bit of food off the surface like
a grown man in a crowded room finger picking a bite of cheese on a
charcuterie board. I grinned before I even casted to him.
I
let a nice easy cast drop my caddis way ahead of his feeding zone
pretty much in the same direction he rose in. I watched my imitation
drift like a caddis resting on the surface before taking off. I
watched the unsuspecting trout sip it up off the surface. I reared
back on the rod and the line tightened once again. He put up a good
fight like it’s been some time ago that he was caught. I grinned
the whole time I brought him to the net.
The
evening was turning cooler and I only discovered one more trout
rising. For the heck of it I knotted on a #16 caddis and lighter wing
color to make it easier to see cause of the water glare and just to
see if that last trout would be fooled. The first cast out towards
him revealed my suspicion. He took it with a healthy slap that caused
a surface splash then just a conspicuous swirl. I reared back on the
long length of line and another trout fought in the current towards
me.
As
I stood thigh high deep in the middle of the crick watching for
another rise a swarm of caddis started to fly upstream like a
murmuration of starlings. Trying to swat one in my hat wasn’t easy
as they avoided all but one attempt. When I did get one in my cap I
carefully opened it up to find an egg laying grannom. I looked upon
the surface water and never saw a trout rise again. It didn’t look
like any of these grannoms were stopping for a drink of water as they
were flying fast upstream as if they didn’t want to be late for a
big celebration. I wished I knew where the celebration was!
With
that I waded out and called it a day.
~doubletaper